Logic, metaphysics and the natural sociability of mankind. The elimination of metaphysics 1611 including all philosophy of value and normative theory, logical analysis yields the negative result that the alleged statements in this domain are entirely meaningless. Modal logic as metaphysics download modal logic as metaphysics ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub, and mobi format. Sentential operators are devices that take sentences to form new sentences. Modal logic as metaphysics hardcover timothy williamson. Start your 48hour free trial to unlock this the logical basis of metaphysics study guide and get instant access to the following analysis. Modal metaphysics internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Phil thesis an examination of theistic conceptual realism as an alternative to theistic activismwelty 2000, his philosophia christi paper the lord of noncontradiction.
Modal logic as metaphysics pdf epub download cause of. Modal metaphysics is a branch of philosophy that investigates the metaphysics underlying statements about possible or a priori statements. Holliday university of california, berkeley abstract this chapter provides a brief introduction to propositional epistemic logic and its applications to epistemology. Perhaps the most obvious instances of the intrusion of logic into metaphysics are certain formulations of the problem of the one and the many. For example, if the question is raised in some such form as being ought to be one, how then is it many, the ought here is a logical demand. Foundations of modal metaphysics phil c3912 fall 2015 friday 24pm description. Modal logic our language semantics relations soundness results theorem n and k hold in all models. Basic results about these concepts are stated and some simple. Metaphysics has always occupied a crucial position in the field of philosophy.
Download pdf modal logic as metaphysics free online. Contains several relevant papers on modal metaphysics, including lewis criticisms of routley a contemporary meinongian and of armstrong. In this seminar, we will discuss foundational questions in the theory of metaphysical possibility. Basic results about these concepts are stated and some simple proofs are given. Browse other questions tagged logic metaphysics modallogic or ask your own question. Therewith a radical elimination of metaphysics is attained. Metaphysics is the branch of philosophy that examines the fundamental nature of reality, including the relationship between mind and matter, between substance and attribute, and between potentiality and actuality. If logic and metaphysics appear disjoint, the reason is not just the lingering spell of a logical positivist conception of metaphysics as cognitively meaningless and logic as. The word metaphysics comes from two greek words that, together, literally mean after or behind or among the study of the natural. Are there such things as merely possible people, who would have lived if our ancestors had acted. Introduction in this article, we canvass a few of the interesting topics that philosophers can pursue as part of the simultaneous study of logic and metaphysics. Jan 01, 20 in modal logic as metaphysics, timothy williamson argues for positive answers to are there future people, who have not yet been conceived.
Penelope rush is honorary associate with the school of philosophy and online lecturer for student learning at the university of tasmania. In modal logic as metaphysics, timothy williamson argues for positive answers to are there future people, who have not yet been conceived. In doing this i began with some enquiries into aristotles metaphysics published by code 3 and produced from this a preliminary model section3. In modal logic as metaphysics, timothy williamson argues for positive answers to those questions on the basis of an integrated approach to the issues, applying the technical resources of modal logic to provide structural cores for metaphysical theories. Logic is metaphysics abstract analyzing the position of two philosophers whose views are recognizably divergent, w. Timothy williamsons modal logic as metaphysics is, among much else, a detailed and complex defense of the metaphysical view he calls necessitism, the view. Modal logic as metaphysics discusses many interesting logical systems and their possible metaphysical significance, but the clarity kripkean model theory initially lent to modal issues in the propositional and firstorder cases does not carry over to the baroque systems of williamsons fancy, which combine so many complicated and poorly. What is the relationship between logic and metaphysics. The word metaphysics comes from two greek words that, together, literally mean after or behind or among the study of the. Nov 10, 2015 there may be something in formal, truthfunctional or quantificational logic that is inherently inadequate if not opposed to sound metaphysics. Descartes modal metaphysics stanford encyclopedia of. Is the notion of metaphysical possibility intelligible. The methodology of modal logic as metaphysics umass blogs.
I have enjoyed the times ive been able to teach it in my courses and have benefited from it numerous times in analyzing the validity of arguments. In my experience, the almost universal assumption in contemporary, analytic philosophy is that every argument in principle can be construed as a simple truthfunctional or a more sophisticated. Williamson is however sympathetic to 5, which he calls the being constraint p. Lewiss view of the relation between modal metaphysics. Semantics of functional terms modal logic and metaphysics. In what follows, however, i want to switch to the role of critic, raising questions i rst about kreines presentation of hegels. The search for a metaphysically neutral logic is rejected as futile. Timothy williamson gives an original and provocative treatment of deep metaphysical questions about existence, contingency, and change, using the latest resources of quantified modal logic.
If you have defined a proper model, you know that rw1, w2 if in your model the pair w1, w2 is in the extension of r. The metaphysics of reason and hegels logic 3 also postcritical in its direct responsiveness to kants critical challenge to the very possibility of metaphysics. Metaphysics is the branch of philosophy that examines the fundamental nature of reality. Contrary to the widespread assumption that logic and metaphysics are disjoint, he argues that modal logic provides a structural core for metaphysics. Logic, metaphysics and the natural sociability of mankind by. One sense in which logic, so construed, is tied up with metaphysical matters is that the question of what the truthmakers of a sentence must be like calls for a specification of the ontology underlying our languagei. Do not be misled by the occurrence of the word logic in the title of the paper. Hegel, to aesthetics logic of beauty on the other, with psychology, epistemology, mathematics etc. A comment on timothy williamsons modal logic as metaphysics louis derosset february 27, 2015 logic, as standardly conceived, is the science of consequence.
Introduction preliminary definition of the subject matter of the history of logic is hard to come by. Jul 11, 2006 perhaps the most obvious instances of the intrusion of logic into metaphysics are certain formulations of the problem of the one and the many. The logic and metaphysics paper covers many of the central problems of philosophy. Philosophy, and analytic metaphysics in particular, is usually described as an armchair discipline, and exactly for such an armchair methodology it has been the.
The most important primary source in modal metaphysics. The most fundamental principle that he derives is the law of noncontradiction a an enti. Mar 01, 2006 until the publication of this liberty fund edition, all but one of the works contained in logic, metaphysics, and the natural sociability of mankind were available only in latin. This milestone english translation will provide a general audience with insight into hutchesons thought. Logical positivism and rejection of metaphysics philosophy. And as such logic has a lot to do with metaphysics. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read modal logic as metaphysics. Methodology the title of this book may sound to some readers like good as evil, or perhaps cabbages as kings. Modal logic as metaphysics ebook written by timothy williamson. Modal logic as metaphysics the philosophical quarterly. Foundations of modal metaphysics columbia university. Regardless of which of the two views one holds about logic, both have it that the subject matter of logic is distinct from that of metaphysics, thereby separating the logical principles from the. Leibnizs modal metaphysics stanford encyclopedia of. If you do not have a model you may be able to infer this from the presumed properties of r, for example from rw0, w1 and rw0, w2 you can infer rw1, w2 if r is euclidean.
Questions like those raise deep issues about both the nature of being and its logical relations with contingency and change. Mar 27, 2017 in traditional philosophy, metaphysics was the branch of philosophy in which philosophers attempted to construct models of reality not accessible to empirical sciences. If so, what are the bounds of metaphysical possibility. Dummett,weintendtosupportastriking point of agreement between them. If is an axiom, then holds in every model, so clearly holds in every model. The researches of applied logic or the theory of knowledge, which aim. But as a thomist who is an enthusiast of henry babcock veatch and others, ive come to see more and. Metaphysics, logic and epistemology university of birmingham. Timothy williamson, modal logic as metaphysics philpapers. It is the branch of philosophy which deals with reality and the questions related to being and the world. Outlines of logic and metaphysics internet archive. No previous exposure to epistemic logic is assumed. Metaphysics logic and the one princeton university. The agenda introduction basic modal logic normal systems of modal logic metatheorems of normal systems variants of modal logic conclusion.
It also contains an overview of the handbook, and a brief history of epistemic logic and pointers to the literature. Dec 08, 2016 the word metaphysics comes from aristotles metaphysics, in which he tries to figure out the most general principles that apply to everything that exists. Divine conceptualism dc is an idea about the ontological relationship between god and abstract objects, defended by greg welty, in his m. The grounds of this ontological aspect of logic were explicitly laid down by aristotle in the metaphysics, where some of the basic laws of logic were held to be among the most certain principles of all things. To answer this question, williamson surveys and critically evaluates a vast array of formulations of quanti. In order to explain leibnizs modal metaphysicsthe metaphysics of necessity, contingency, and possibilitywe must look first at the foundation of leibnizs system more generally. An introduction to modal logic 2009 formosan summer school on logic, language, and computation 29 june10 july, 2009. In traditional philosophy, metaphysics was the branch of philosophy in which philosophers attempted to construct models of reality not accessible to empirical sciences. Outlines of logic and metaphysics by erdmann, johann eduard, 18051892. Lewiss view of the relation between modal metaphysics and modal logic couldnt be more different. His work in these areas has been particularly influential in shaping debates about metaphysical modality, which is the topic of his recent provocative and closelyargued book modal logic as metaphysics 20. Is it the case that once assuming only one logic we actually ascribe logic a metaphysical status in the form of say laws of thought, and once allowing all sorts of logic we rather deontologize logic and turn it into mere instrument. Modal logic as metaphysics by timothy williamson books on. Ambitious new work by one of the worlds leading philosophers.
Timothy williamson is one of the most influential living philosophers working in the areas of logic and metaphysics. The word metaphysics comes from aristotles metaphysics, in which he tries to figure out the most general principles that apply to everything that exists. There is detailed historical discussion of how the metaphysical issues emerged in the twentiethcentury development of quantified modal logic, through the work of such figures as rudolf carnap, ruth barcan marcus, arthur prior, saul kripke, david lewis, robert stalnaker, alvin. Publication date 1896 topics logic, metaphysics publisher london, s.
Pdf modal logic as metaphysics download full pdf book. A semantic perspective 3 chapters in this handbook. Click download or read online button to modal logic as metaphysics book pdf for free now. Posts about metaphysics of logic written by apmalpass. Cresswell, modal logic as metaphysics, the philosophical quarterly, volume 64, issue 255, april 2014, pages 332338. Tahko department of philosophy durham university ph.
1430 1639 1590 1481 522 361 888 358 211 1188 88 1218 388 1092 1403 1577 1081 895 1374 748 604 1124 831 574 71 930 1002 1067 727 297 737 260